So, I downloaded RDR. I've played it a few times and it went smoothly. The disc hasn't been removed from the Xbox since I've successfully played it, so it's in fine condition. The Xbox is playing other games fine.
That said, when I put RDR in... No success lol. It's as if a timer is put into effect when it realizes RDR is in my disc tray lol. If I turn my xbox on, use the bathroom and come back, it freezes on start up. If I turn my xbox on, and immediately press A to play RDR, I get to the title screen, I can press start. The 3 options at the bottom appear. I press A for single player, and the other 2 options disappear. (A Button) Single Player stays on my screen, and it just freezes up there. The guide button still works, etc. But no movement on screen and no activity for 10 mins when I went to cook some food.